Overview
The Gravity paper showed that the horizontal variation of the projective spectral entropy functional \[ S_\Pi[g] = \tfrac{1}{2}\log\det' A_g \] with respect to the base metric produces the Einstein tensor as the infrared-dominant response, via the Seeley–DeWitt coefficient $a_2$.
Q12 carries out the complementary vertical variation. The operator $A_g$ is extended to \[ A_{g,\mathcal{A}} = -(\nabla^{\mathcal{A}})^2 + E \] on the associated vector bundle of the admissible principal fibre $P_{G_\Pi}(M, G_\Pi)$, and the Seeley–DeWitt coefficient $a_4$ is computed.
The extended functional $S_\Pi[g,\mathcal{A}]$ contains the renormalized Yang–Mills term with logarithmic coupling, and its vertical variation yields the Yang–Mills equations $D_\mu F^{a\mu\nu} = 0$ in the current-free sector.
Core contributions
- Extension to vector bundle: the spectral operator $A_g$ is lifted to $A_{g,\mathcal{A}}$ on the associated bundle, incorporating the admissible gauge connection $\mathcal{A}$ from Q6a/O31.
- $a_4$ coefficient and Yang–Mills term: isolating the gauge component $\Omega^{\mathrm{gauge}}_{\mu\nu} = F_{\mu\nu}$ of the total bundle curvature, \[ a_4(A_{g,\mathcal{A}})\big|_{\mathrm{gauge}} = \int \frac{1}{12}\,\mathrm{tr}_\rho(F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu})\sqrt{g}\,\mathrm{d}^4x, \] with the overall $(4\pi)^{-2}$ carried once by the heat-kernel prefactor. The induced logarithmic running of $g_{\mathrm{YM}}^{-2}$ has coefficient $I_\rho/(3\cdot 16\pi^2)$ — the entropy term carries $I_\rho/(12\cdot 16\pi^2)$ for $\int F^2$, which matches $(4g_{\mathrm{YM}}^2)^{-1}$ rather than $g_{\mathrm{YM}}^{-2}$ — depending on the representation through the Dynkin index $I_\rho$, hence not universal.
- Vertical variation yields Yang–Mills equations: $\delta_{\mathcal{A}} S_\Pi[g,\mathcal{A}] = 0$ gives $D_\mu F^{a\mu\nu} = 0$ (proved for the $a_4$ derivation given $G_\Pi$).
- Difference in UV divergence degree: within a proper-time cutoff, the Einstein term diverges quadratically (order $a_2$) and the Yang–Mills term logarithmically (order $a_4$). This difference is structural in that scheme and is not scheme-independent — the zeta-regularized determinant carries no power divergences. The physical couplings $g_{\mathrm{YM}}$ and $G_N$ are renormalized matching data, and only the logarithmic running is computed. No predictive formula for $G_N$ and no tuning-free hierarchy is claimed (consistent with Gravity 3.3).
- Vertical variation at fixed metric: at fixed base metric, the vertical variation isolates the Yang–Mills sector. Full horizontal–vertical decoupling does not hold: the metric variation of $F^2$ is the Yang–Mills energy–momentum tensor $T^{\mathrm{YM}}_{\mu\nu}$, an $a_4$-order back-reaction treated in Q13.
Spectral stratification as an organisational principle
Beyond the technical derivation, Q12 identifies a conceptual principle that distinguishes the Cosmochrony approach from conventional unification schemes.
In standard group-theoretic unification, gravity and gauge interactions are sought at the same algebraic level — different representations of a common group $G_{\mathrm{unif}}$. Their combination requires finding a symmetry large enough to accommodate both.
The present framework suggests a different picture: gravity and gauge dynamics are separated by geometric direction (horizontal vs. vertical variation on the admissible bundle) and by spectral order ($a_2$ vs. $a_4$ in the Seeley–DeWitt hierarchy). Their distinct UV behaviours — quadratic divergence for gravity, logarithmic for gauge — are structural consequences of this separation, not independent empirical inputs.
Relation to the Cosmochrony programme
Q12 is the vertical counterpart to the Gravity paper. Each sector follows from the same functional by varying in a different direction; joining the two variations, and the conditional system that results, belongs to Q13:
- Gravity paper: $\delta_g S_\Pi = 0 \implies G_{\mu\nu} = 8\pi G_N T^{(\Pi)}_{\mu\nu}$
- Q12: $\delta_{\mathcal{A}} S_\Pi = 0 \implies D_\mu F^{a\mu\nu} = 0$
The gauge group $G_\Pi$ is inherited from Q6a/O31. The SU(3) sector is unconditional at the pointwise level: $[H\text{-color}]_{\mathrm{pointwise}}$ (exact equality $\sigma_c(n) = \sigma_{\omega c}(n) = \sigma_{\omega^2 c}(n)$ at finite $q$) is proved analytically in O31 v1.5 (Proposition 4.23) via the single-frequency structure of the Born–Infeld fingerprint.
The joint variation — the conditional Einstein–Yang–Mills system and the $a_4$-order back-reaction $T^{\mathrm{YM}}_{\mu\nu}$ — is carried out in Q13, where the couplings likewise remain independent renormalized matching data, so no numerical value for $G_N g_{\mathrm{YM}}^2$ follows.
Open directions
- SU(3) Yang–Mills uniqueness: prove that the SU(3) gauge dynamics emerge uniquely from the colour triplet co-admissibility structure, without inputting the group as data (O31 §9.2).
- Matter sector: extend the vertical variation to include projected matter currents $J^{a\nu}$.
- Spectral stratification beyond order 4: investigate whether higher Seeley–DeWitt coefficients $a_6$, $a_8$ produce further interaction sectors or remain suppressed.
References
Jérôme Beau. Yang–Mills Dynamics from Projective Spectral Entropy: Vertical Heat-Kernel Variation on the Admissible Fibre, 2026. doi:10.5281/zenodo.20189137